Prof. Michael Heap, redaktor naczelny kwartalnika The Skeptical Intelligencer publikowanego przez Association for Skeptical Inquiry w nr 3 z 2015 roku (Vol 18, 2015, Number 3, Autumn) zamieścił recenzję naszej książki. Oto jej pełen tekst:
The failings of modern psychology are the subject of a recent book by Tomasz Witkowski and Maciej Zatonoski entitledPsychology Gone Wrong: The Dark Sides of Science and Therapy (Boca Raton FL: BrownWalker Press, 2015). The authors are founding members of the Polish Skeptics Club. Dr Witkowski is a psychologist and Dr Zatonski is a surgeon working in the UK. In their book they review the history of fraudulent research and questionable research practices; the willingness of many psychologists to embrace pseudoscientific ideas and practices (psychoanalysis, recovered memory therapy, projective testing, NLP, etc.); exaggerated claims for the efficacy of psychological interventions; and so on. In each case the authors support their thesis with abundant references.
Some readers may find the authors’ style rather uncompromising and without balance (e.g. in their account of ‘the Burt affair’ which was discussed in the Skeptical Adversaria, 2012 (2); Burt does have his defenders). Also, quite a number of the frauds that the authors describe are from disciplines other than psychology and it may be argued that the authors’ complaints are characteristic of science generally (though I think there is a strong case for looking at psychology for particularly instructive examples of ‘science gone wrong’). Readers will wish that the authors included an index and I would advise that when the second edition is in preparation, a good proof reader is employed (the authors should be congratulated on producing an easy-to-read book but even the most forgiving of readers will not excuse the number of errors in the text).
For professional psychologists, students and anyone who needs a working knowledge of academic and applied psychology (which includes all skeptics) this is an important book and I thoroughly recommend it.